Despite stable returns and attractive diversification, mortgages are underrepresented in the portfolios of most pension funds due to the high barriers to entry, regulatory requirements and limited liquidity. Investment foundations can take over both credit assessment and portfolio management, and thus facilitate access to this asset class for investors.
Mortgages play only a minor role in the portfolios of most pension funds, often accounting for less than two percent. Institutional investors who want to invest in mortgages need specialized processes and a deep understanding of credit assessment and risk evaluation. The regulatory requirements are complex, and it is necessary to ensure broad diversification within the mortgage portfolio. These requirements prevent many pension funds from investing in mortgages despite the stable income and diversification offered.
Investment foundations facilitate access
One solution to this problem is to invest in mortgages via an investment foundation. These foundations pool the capital of several investors and handle everything from credit checks and risk management to portfolio management. In this way, pension funds benefit from professional management and broad diversification without having to fulfill operational and regulatory requirements themselves. This significantly lowers the barriers to entry and also gives smaller pension funds access to this attractive asset class.
Another reservation concerns the limited liquidity of mortgages. Unlike listed securities, mortgages cannot be sold at any time. For many institutional investors who require a high level of liquidity in their portfolios, this appears problematic at first glance. However, investors receive an illiquidity premium to compensate for the limited tradability, which leads to additional returns in a diversified portfolio.
Achieve additional returns with mortgages
Compared to traditional bonds with comparable risks, a key advantage of mortgages is their high yield. While government and corporate bonds often deliver hardly any returns in periods of low interest rates and sometimes even have negative yields, mortgages offer more stable and higher returns. As a rule, they generate an additional return of around 80 to 100 basis points compared to bonds with a comparable credit rating and term.
Development of Swiss mortgage interest rates, interest rates on comparable Confederation bonds and the Swiss Bond Index (AAA-A)
While bond investors have to make do with minimal returns, mortgage investors benefit from a structural bonus that is additionally supported by the mortgage collateral.
Steady and stable interest income with relatively calculable risks
Mortgages represent debt financing that is secured by mortgage liens. This enables a considerable reduction in the risk of default. The return is primarily determined by the interest income. Mortgages therefore offer a clearly calculable and steady return. If mortgages are valued at market value and based on current market interest rates, interest rate changes will also lead to corresponding fluctuations in the portfolio for mortgage investments. If the loan-to-value ratios are taken into account alongside other factors, this helps to determine the probability of a mortgage default and to calculate the risk.
Pension funds and insurance companies are significantly underrepresented in the overall mortgage market compared to banks. Banks traditionally claim the lion's share of the market volume. Institutional investors such as pension funds have so far only had a limited share of this market. This reluctance is due to historical reasons and can be attributed to aspects including the aforementioned barriers to entry and regulatory challenges. However, the mortgage market offers considerable growth potential for institutional investors. As banks are reducing some of their mortgage lending due to stricter capital requirements, pension funds and insurance companies can step into this gap and thus realize attractive returns. They benefit not only from the relative security and stability of the asset class, but also from the opportunity to strategically diversify their exposure.
Effective protection against negative interest rates
Particularly in periods of low interest rates, when many bonds offer very low or even negative yields, mortgages offer not only an attractive return but also effective protection against negative interest rates. This advantage results from the stable cash flows guaranteed by the minimum interest rates for borrowers. In an environment where investors are increasingly having to pay for liquidity or highly liquid bonds, this protection remains a key factor in achieving attractive total returns. At the same time, mortgage collateralization offers a level of security that traditional bonds often do not achieve. If a borrower becomes insolvent, the value of the underlying property is retained. The risk of loss is therefore significantly reduced.
Mortgages can be considered an effective diversification alternative to bonds due to their stable cash flow, low volatility and high collateralization. The combination of security and potential returns opens up attractive opportunities for pension funds. By integrating mortgages into their investment strategy as an integral component, institutional investors benefit not only from stable returns but also from optimal protection for their portfolios against falling interest rates.
All information in this article has been compiled with care and to the best of our knowledge and belief. Zurich Invest Ltd. and Zurich Investment Foundation assume no responsibility for the accuracy and completeness of the information and disclaim any liability for losses arising from the use of this information. The opinions expressed in this article are those of Zurich Invest Ltd. and Zurich Investment Foundation at the time of writing and are subject to change without notice. This article is for information purposes only and is intended solely for the recipient. This article constitutes neither a solicitation nor an invitation to make an offer, to conclude a contract or to buy or sell investment instruments and is no substitute for detailed advice or a tax review. A purchase decision must be made on the basis of the articles of association, the regulations and the investment guidelines as well as the latest annual report of the Zurich Investment Foundation. This article may not be reproduced in whole or in part without the written permission of the Zurich Investment Foundation or Zurich Invest Ltd. It is expressly not intended for persons whose nationality or domicile prohibits access to such information under the applicable legislation. Every investment involves risks, in particular fluctuations in value and income. In the case of foreign currencies, there is an additional risk that the foreign currency may lose value against the investor's reference currency. Historical performance is not an indicator of current or future performance. The performance data does not take into account any commissions and costs charged on the issue and redemption of units. The issuer and manager of the investment groups is Zurich Investment Foundation, Hagenholzstrasse 60, 8050 Zurich. The custodian bank is State Street Bank International GmbH, Munich, Zurich branch. The managing director of the Zurich Investment Foundation is Zurich Invest Ltd, Hagenholzstrasse 60, 8050 Zurich. The articles of association, regulations and investment guidelines as well as the current annual report and factsheets can be obtained free of charge from the Zurich Investment Foundation. They can also be viewed at www.zurich-anlagestiftung.ch. Only tax-exempt pension funds domiciled in Switzerland are authorised as investors in the Zurich Investment Foundation.
Macro and Market Publications
On Zurich's website you will find interesting publications on current economic and market topics. Learn more about financial market-related developments and trends now.
On Zurich's Austrasse, a now completed project has transformed unused office space into new living space. With an occupancy rate of 95 percent, it's achieved crucial success. Particularly worthy of note are its sustainability, innovative energy concepts and social aspects, which were central to its development.
Our online report provides information on the environmentally relevant key figures for Swiss real estate and now shows a year-on-year comparison of the key figures for equities and bonds.